Pennsylvania Protect Your Rights,
Know Their Records

A Hunter's Guide to Researching PA Supreme Court Justices

Pennsylvania hunters know that nothing worth keeping comes easy. Every season demands effort, patience, and skill. The same principle should apply to our courts. This November, three Pennsylvania Supreme Court justices, Christine Donohue, Kevin Dougherty, and David Wecht, are asking for another ten years on the bench. That is not something to hand out freely.

HN-PA-25-SCE_Kevin_Dougherty

Kevin Dougherty

HN-PA-25-SCE_David_Wecht

David Wecht

HN-PA-25-SCE_Christine_Donahue

Christine Donahue

A judicial retention vote gives every voter the power to decide whether these judges have earned another term. They are counting on the public to remain quiet and simply check 'yes'. Hunters do not take shortcuts, and we should not start now. It is time to hold them accountable, study their records, and make sure our votes reflect our values.

Step 1: Know Their Approach to the Law

Before you decide whether a justice deserves another ten years, understand how they interpret the law. Every ruling comes down to one of two philosophies.

  • Interpret the Law as Written: Judges who take this approach focus on the Constitution and the plain meaning of the law. They believe their job is to apply it, not change it. This mindset protects individual rights and ensures that lawmakers, not judges, make policy. For hunters, that means stronger safeguards for the Second Amendment and for property rights that protect access to land.
  • Legislate from the Bench: Judges who follow this path use their power to shape policy through interpretation. They may stretch or redefine the law to fit modern political ideas. This approach often appears in cases involving gun control, election laws, or environmental regulation, where rulings can override the will of the people.

Look at how each justice has ruled on key constitutional cases. Their opinions reveal whether they respect the limits of their authority or use the bench to advance an agenda.

Play Video

PA State Representative Jamie Barton
Pennsylvania's 124th Legislative District

Play Video

PA State Representative Tim O'Neal
Pennsylvania's 48th Legislative District

Play Video

PA State Representative Eric Davanzo
Pennsylvania's 58th Legislative District

Step 2: Where to Find Their Records

Judges do not campaign on specific issues, so voters need to do their own homework. The best way to understand a justice’s record is to rely on trusted organizations that review rulings, track judicial behavior, and publish evaluations based on clear criteria

Gun Owners of America (GOA): This group reviews judicial decisions that affect the Second Amendment. Check their public scorecards and reports. A consistent pattern of low grades shows a history of rulings that weaken the right to keep and bear arms.

America First Works: This organization focuses on how judges handle issues of constitutional authority and election integrity. Read their research summaries to see how each justice ruled in cases dealing with government power, voting laws, and individual rights.

National Rifle Association (NRA): conducts judicial review primarily through its lobbying arm, the NRA Institute for Legislative Action (NRA-ILA). It does not typically use simple A-F scorecards but instead engages in and supports litigation, issuing detailed legal reports on court cases that affect the Second Amendment, such as the landmark Supreme Court decision in NYSRPA v. Bruen.

Your most effective research comes from looking directly at their rulings. Ask yourself which side of the argument each justice has supported in major constitutional cases over the past decade.

Step 3: Make Your Own Informed Decision

Hunter Nation believes every voter has the right and responsibility to think for themselves. This election is not about following a party line or a headline. It is about protecting the values that define who we are as hunters and as citizens.

If you believe a justice has upheld the Constitution and defended individual rights, vote yes to keep them. If you believe a justice has ignored the law or ruled in ways that threaten your freedoms, vote no and call for change.

Hunt The Vote

Be ready to vote on November 4. Take a few minutes now to check your registration, review the judges’ records, and make a plan to cast your ballot. Visit HuntTheVote.org/PA for tools and resources to help you make an informed choice.

Play Video
Play Video
Play Video

Leave a Comment